North Pond might be the only restaurant in the country that went from a homeless shelter to serving haute cuisine. Built in 1912, the Arts and Crafts-style building located in the heart of Lincoln Park on the edge of the North Pond nature sanctuary was originally a warming hut for ice skaters. Over the years, it also served as a storage shed, a hot dog stand and a city shelter for the homeless
Richard Mott operated a series of concessions at the University of Chicago, Northwestern and other local universities. His business was seasonal and he was looking to even out revenue in the summer. When he saw the former warming hut, it reminded him of Tavern on the Green in New York’s Central Park.
North Pond Cafe opened in 1998, serving low-country cuisine such as rabbit and grits. At that time, Sherman had just bought his first house and quit his job as a chef at the Ritz-Carlton. While working on the home and pondering his next move, he answered a blind ad in the Tribune and was hired at North Pond in the fall of 1999. Sherman, who had learn to cook seasonally with what was available at corner vegetable stands while living in India, reimagined the restaurant as a seasonal, local farm-sourced temple of cuisine. Over the next two years, Sherman, who became a partner, dropped “cafe” from name of the restaurant and oversaw a renovation that replaced a section of weather-dependent outdoor seating with a permanent addition that included a fireplace and bar.
Cooking seasonally and locally in 1999 was rare. “When I said my cooking was seasonal, one of our first customers asked me, `Which seasons are you open?” he said. Today, where “green” cooking is everywhere, Sherman is still one of its foremost practitioners. In an era of small plates and chemical stabilizers, Sherman’s legendary corn soup, regularly served in the late summer or early fall, derives a simple magic from sweet corn recently plucked from the stalk. “As I grow older, I’m less fussy. We’re in an age and stage [of cuisine] where it’s about tweezers and less about substance than it was 15 years ago,” Sherman said.
If that sounds unfashionable, that’s because it is. North Pond is the antithesis of hip. Not kowtowing to trends is the very essence of Sherman and North Pond’s success — North Pond has a Michelin star and Sherman was named a James Beard Award-winning Best Chef for the Great Lakes region in 2012.
In a time when you have to fight your friends for that last bacon-wrapped something on a shared plate or shout above loud conversations to be heard, North Pond is a respite. Sherman serves an appetizer-entree format or an elegant chef-driven fixed tasting menu ($90), and is practicing some the highest cooking craft of any restaurant in the city. On a snowy evening, with the roaring fireplace and the big pond beyond the front dining room windows, being here feels like you left the city and are dining at a weekend cottage in Michigan designed by Frank Lloyd Wright. If you’re beginning a great love story and looking for a space to share your dreams with a special someone, North Pond is the spot.
The essentials: North Pond
2610 N. Cannon Drive 773-477-5845
This article first appeared in Redeye Chicago in a different form.